Magistrate judge paul grimm ruled creative pipe had waived attorneyclient privilege when it inadvertently produced several electronic documents. The signature certifies that to the best of the persons knowledge, information, and belief formed after a reasonable. Follow judge clearys lead or for you eastcoasters, judge paul grimms lead in mancia v. Grimm for the cell site location for the period of july 1, 2010 through february 6, 2011. Paul grimm is a united states magistrate judge sitting in the united states district court for the district of maryland, in baltimore. While different proportionality limits may be used that vary from judge grimms suggested maximum limits of 15 categories, 10 custodians, 5 years, and 160 hours, this is a good start for most. Strategy and tactics by edward imwinklereid and theodore blumoff. Peck have become the linchpin in the evolution of ediscovery case law. Marriott data breach judge puts lawyers on a fast track. Paul grimm judge grimm serves as a district judge for the united states district court for the district of maryland. The increasing importance of rule 26g in ediscovery. Fax, and paul mark sandler paperback american bar association 2005 hon.
Jackson lewis principal ralph losey authors ediscovery. The judge grimm discovery order goes well beyond serving as a guide to 26f. Grimm serves as a district judge for the united states district court for the district of maryland. Download ebook discovery problems and their solutions pdf. Judge paul grimms new discovery order, which, to my knowledge, he now enters in every medium or large size case before him in district. District court for the district of maryland, since. Grimm serves as a district judge for the united states district. Coauthor, discovery problems and their solutions, 2004. Adjunct faculty, university of maryland school of law, and university of baltimore school of law. Grimm found that ivs conduct in obtaining and enforcing its patents was immune from antitrust liability based on the noerrpennington doctrine. He also teaches courses on these subjects at the university of maryland school of law and the university of baltimore school of law. Judge grimms new discovery order is now an ediscovery best. Paul mark sandler discovery problems and their solutions, third edition teaches effective discovery.
The above quote is courtesy of chief magistrate judge paul w. Ralphs contributions to ediscovery have been essential in providing premier legal representation in the current legal and it fields, said john m. Nov 26, 2010 the above quote is courtesy of chief magistrate judge paul w. The symposium featured four panels of scholars discussing their recent work in the area of ediscovery, a keynote address delivered by u. Always conduct diligent, reasonable discovery triad. Friending electronic evidence outline by the honorable john m. Social media discovery, part 2 the threshold question. Grimm found creative pipe waived the privilege because it had failed to work out a privilege search protocol with the opposition, it had declined to use a clawback agreement, and it had. Discovery problems and their solutions ebook by paul w. Atkinsonbaker discovery problems and their solutions. Judge paul grimms new discovery order, which, to my knowledge, he now enters in every medium or large size case before him in district court in maryland, has just been included in electronic discovery best practices found at. Dec 02, 2016 featuring a foreword by judge paul grimm, the book has been well received by leaders in the field of ediscovery. Fax and sandler interweave practical advice with salient case law and keen observations honed by decades of experience.
Fax and sandler interweave practical advice with case law and keen observations. Discovery problems and their solutions kindle edition by. Bridging the gap between theory and practice, the authors, the hon. In this employment case, plaintiffs filed several motions to compel supplemental responses to their extensive discovery requests after defendants allegedly failed to adequately respond. Implications of lorraine in authenticating evidence for e. Grimm is the appointed united states chief magistrate judge for the district court for the district of maryland. District judge paul grimm, in an opinion granting in part and denying a motion to. Reacting to the precedent established by the recent supreme court case united states v. The assimilation of his order into edbp was fairly easy because judge grimms order reaffirms all of his many prior teachings and articles, and that of. Grimm, district judge district of maryland united states. The census must be conducted in a way that will not thwart the goal of equal representation, wrote u. Intellectual ventures prevails in capital one antitrust.
As a magistrate judge, grimm handled all the duties of a federal court. Susman godfrey llp 1201 third avenue, suite 3800 seattle, wa 98101 honorable paul w. District judge paul grimm, who is overseeing nearly 100 lawsuits brought over marriotts data breach, told lawyers at a hearing. Featuring a foreword by judge paul grimm, the book has been well received by leaders in the field of ediscovery.
Previously, he was appointed to the court as a magistrate judge in february 1997 and served as chief magistrate judge from 2006 through 2012. Sandler and charles fax, discovery problems and their solutions. News marriott data breach judge puts lawyers on a fast track u. Module b judge shira scheindlin on the new rules2006 and ralph losey on rule 37e. Grimm is chief magistrate judge for the united states district court. Grimm of the district of maryland has been writing about spoliation and evidentiary concerns for quite some time see, e.
Judge paul grimm, the chief magistrate judge of the united states district court of maryland, in. Judicial perspectives on the proposed frcp ediscovery amendments. Discovery problems and their solutions, third edition teaches effective discovery. Oct 28, 20 judge grimms new discovery order is now an ediscovery best practice part one judge paul grimms new discovery order, which, to my knowledge, he now enters in every medium or large size case before him in district court in maryland, has just been included in electronic discovery best practices found at. Manual on best practices for authenticating digital evidence, by judge paul grimm, professor dan capra and greg. Magistrate judge paul grimm ruled creative pipe had waived. Judge paul grimms newdiscovery order, which, to my knowledge, he now enters in every medium or large size case before him in district court in maryland,has just been included in electronic discovery best practices found at. In addition, the court held that capital one was barred from relitigating its antitrust claims based upon a 2014 ruling from a virginia federal court. The increasing importance of rule 26g in ediscovery exterro.
Based on our ruling on grimms title ix claim, the district court issued an order dated june 23, 2016, granting grimms motion for a preliminary injunction and requiring the school board to allow grimm to use bathrooms designated for males. Paul grimm, a federal magistrate judge, and experienced litigators charles fax and paul sandler, set forth more than 50 typical hypothetical situations, and then engage in a concise and authoritative discussion of the case law on both sides of the issues. In 2008 ruling, judge paul grimm called rule 26g the most underutilized and misunderstood rule in the book, but only cited it to support his main point of cooperation, instead of imposing sanctions. With magistrate judge paul grimms recent decision in mancia v. Jones in conjunction with the application of the third party doctrine, judge richard d. Hes been one of the leading judges on ediscovery in his opinions and. Module d part one of a lecture by judge paul grimm on the application of the rules of evidence to electronically stored information. Paul mark sandler is an active trial lawyer representing many notable clients in a wide variety of cases in state and federal courts. Judge grimms new discovery order is now an ediscovery. The case was eventually referred to chief united states magistrate judge paul grimm for the purpose of resolving all of the discovery disputes.
Module d part one of a lecture by judge paul grimm on the application of the. A federal judge in baltimore enforced rule 26gs mandatory sanctions provision for the first time since it first went into effect in 1983. Discovery problems and their solutions fax, charles s. Since 1960, the united states civil justice system has witnessed a litigation. Ubumd american college of trial lawyers advanced trial. It requires attorneys and parties practicing before judge grimm to conduct discovery proportionally, and then goes into specifics as to what that means in his courtroom. Esi bytes is a free resource on electronic discovery where top experts share their opinions and tips. Judge grimm has written numerous books and articles on subjects including electronic discovery, civil procedure, evidence and trial practice and lectures frequently on these topics. Judge grimm serves as a district judge for the united states district court for the district of maryland. From 1984 until 1997, judge grimm worked in private practice handling commercial litigation until his appointment as united states magistrate judge. Discovery problems and their solutions edition 3 by charles. Via electronic discovery law comes an opinion so thorough and helpful its hard to believe you can get it for free magistrate judge paul w.
Judicial perspectives on the proposed frcp ediscovery. Grimm is chief magistrate judge for the united states district court, district of maryland, and as an adjunct professor of law at the university of maryland school of law. Grimm, and a round table discussion with sitting federal judges to consider advances in and future challenges of discovery. Discovery problems and their solutionsthird edition teaches effective discovery. Paul grimm, a federal magistrate judge, and experienced litigators charles fax and paul sandler, set forth more than 50 typical hypothetical situations, and then engage in a concise and authoritative discussion of. The record includes multiple written opinions from u. Grimm, a recognized expert in ediscovery issues, who was brought in to. Previously, he was appointed to the court as a magistrate judge in february 1997 and. Admissibility and authentication of digital evidence two charts and one article, coauthored by judge paul grimm, greg joseph and the staff of practical law magazine. Repeated ediscovery violations can be costly to a client. Grimm is a frequent speaker on ediscovery and has written numerous books and articles on evidence, procedure and trial practice, and is an adjunct faculty member of the university of maryland and. We have long seen general principles of discovery inform the development of the law in the realm of electronic discovery.
Judge grimms revised discovery order expands definition. Jackson lewis principal ralph losey authors ediscovery for. The discovery order judge paul grimm uses in his cases serves as an excellent best practice model for all judges and attorneys in the country. He was appointed to the court on december 10, 2012. Judge grimm has written numerous books and articles on subjects including electronic discovery, civil procedure, evidence and trial practice and lectures. Important developments since the second edition are looked at. Mar 27, 2017 module b judge shira scheindlin on the new rules2006 and ralph losey on rule 37e. Grimms standard discovery order, which we recommend to state and federal court judges alike as a model and inspiration to manage the pretrial discovery process so as to reduce the cost and burden of discovery. District court, district maryland date report 042920 title article ill judges indicate active senior status. Looking back on zubulake, 10 years later aba journal. By charles samuel fax, paul mark sandler and paul w grimm. Lorraine, which is getting more traction by the day, establishes guidelines for admitting electronically stored information esi into evidence.
Sep 01, 2014 looking back on zubulake, 10 years later. Module b judge shira scheindlin on the 2006 ediscovery rule revisions and ralph losey on the 2006 version of rule 37e. Since discovery is more limited in criminal cases, there are fewer opportunities tocontest. Grimm, who recently issued a jarring opinion from the district of maryland, victor stanley inc. Magistrate decisions by judges like the honorable john m facciola, honorable paul grimm, and honorable andrew j. Mayflower and put a price tag on absurdly overbroad requests and obfuscating boilerplate objections. Previously, he was appointed to the court as a magistrate judge in february 1997 and served as.
In february, the american bar association published a new book, discovery problems and their solutions by paul w. Grimm, now widely regarded as an expert on ediscovery, addressed the application of the evidentiary standards to electronically stored information in 2007, when he was chief magistrate judge. These are but a few of the many excellent resources listed in the discovery section of bboard research page. Facciola 1 despite neverending efforts of the bench and bar to reduce the cost and complexity of discovery in civil cases, discovery continues to be the most expensive and timeconsuming aspect of civil litigation. Discovery problems and their solutions by charles s. The book provides an overview of discovery rules and guidelines and covers.
839 1072 1401 78 798 731 93 351 87 1404 1357 1006 756 721 686 241 50 588 841 441 121 684 361 494 402 238 696 1435 617 1492 766 138 13 350 1336 247 1188 93 810 342 420 444 1138 992 101